Dr Peter Cheevers account of tutoring a student for one
hour in IB Philosophy.
The tutorial was wide ranging, as set out below. In regard to the
mechanics of the exam I stressed the importance of answering the question and
not wavering in this. I encouraged the circling of key words in the question. 1. The first possible exam question to be discussed was
the Cosmological Argument i.e. something caused the
Universe to exist, and this First Cause is what we call God. It has been used
by various theologians and philosophers over the centuries, from the ancient
Greeks Plato and Aristotle to the medieval (e.g., St. Thomas Aquinas). The
cosmological argument requires a self-originated motion to cause action.
However the argument falters when the proponents of a first cause (God) fall
back on the theory that the First Cause is exempt from the question 'who then
caused the first cause?' God is outside our concept of time, cause and motion.
Yet, the argument persists, if he is outside it how can s/he intervene?H
|
No comments:
Post a Comment